If you pile on blame whenever your project team member slips up, other employees watch your reactions, and it keeps them on their toes, which is often more counterproductive. To help employees work efficiently and productively, build a culture of psychological safety instead.
In this article, we’ll show you how to do that.
What Is Psychological Safety?
According to a foundational 1999 study by Harvard researcher Amy Edmondson published in Administrative Science Quarterly, psychological safety is a shared belief among team members that it's safe to take interpersonal risks together.
In practice, that means people can admit a mistake, ask a question, or raise a concern without worrying it will damage how they're seen on the team.
Most importantly, employees who feel psychologically safe are likely to be more engaged. According to Gallup's Q12 Meta-Analysis, based on a study of over 183,000 business units, engaged teams are 14% more productive and 23% more profitable than disengaged ones.
6 Ways to Build Psychological Safety Across Your Team
Here’s how to build a safety culture in your team:
1. Make open communication the default.
If someone says "I think we're behind" and gets brushed off, they won't bring you the next problem either. They'll just sit on it.
Gregor Emmian, Deputy Chief Digital Growth Officer at Rise, a zero-commission trading platform that uses real-time AI to help traders make faster decisions, has seen this happen before on his team. "The way you respond to one uncomfortable moment tells the whole team what's allowed going forward. If you treat every flag as useful information rather than a problem to manage, people will open up, see you as a go-to source for solutions, and keep bringing you flags. That's exactly what you want."
To build that habit into your team's routine, do this:
- Use red, amber, green status updates and actually respond well when someone reports red
- Go around the room during standups and reviews so quieter voices get a turn too
- Before jumping to your own opinion, ask a follow-up question first: "Tell me more about what you're seeing"
You should also keep a running list of concerns that don't fit the current agenda, and set a specific time each week to revisit them
2. Treat mistakes as information rather than blame.
The truth is, delivery might not go exactly as planned every time. Estimates can come in wrong, vendors might miss handoffs, and scope has a way of creeping sideways no matter how tightly you manage it.
None of that is unusual, and many other teams experience it. What determines whether your team improves or stays stuck is how you respond when it happens.
If mistakes lead to blame, people hide them until they can't be hidden anymore. If mistakes lead to learning, your team gets sharper with every project.
So, choose the latter. Run postmortem checks, a Google philosophy, by gently asking what happened and what could change next time to streamline delivery.
3. Build empathy into how the team works.
Every employee reacts to situations differently. That’s why direct feedback that one teammate takes in stride might land as harsh for another, depending on how they process things.
So, take your time to be as familiar as possible with how each person takes in feedback, the best way to present it without tipping a mine off, and even which words to avoid.
You can create a "working with me" one-pager in which each person shares their preferences and communication style. Makes it easier to avoid misunderstandings under pressure.
4. Make goals clear and shared.
If your team members aren't sure what they're aiming for, they hold back and second-guess decisions. They might even wait for someone else to make the first move instead of taking initiative.
That means vague goals create hesitation, and hesitation slows everything down, including delivery.
You can fix this by setting goals together rather than handing them down.
Bryan Henry, Founder and President of PeterMD, one of North America's largest online men's health clinics serving over 400,000 patients, applies this same principle across his clinical and operational teams. "Unclear expectations erode trust faster than almost anything else. When people don't know what they're working toward, they default to playing it safe instead of doing what actually needs to happen. We avoided that by keeping our goals explicit, revisiting them often, and making sure everyone understands how their piece fits into the bigger outcome."
In addition, you can include the trade-offs and be upfront about what you've decided not to prioritize. Also, keep milestones and decisions in a shared space, such as project management software, instead of in Slack or an email thread nobody reads twice.
5. Leadership has to model it first.
Your team pays closer attention to how you react than to anything. If you respond to bad news by looking for someone to blame, they will eventually stop bringing bad news and stack it off till it becomes a bigger problem. In the long run, they too will start looking for who to blame for their errors instead of working together to devise a solution.
Moreover, if you, as a leader, never admit uncertainty, nobody else will either.
According to Lankitha Wimalarathna, Founder & CEO of Hiveage: "I used to think admitting uncertainty in front of the team made me look less capable," he says. "The opposite happened. The first time I stood up and said 'I called that wrong, here's what I missed,' people started telling me about problems two weeks earlier than they used to. Silence was never safety - it was just everyone waiting to see if I'd own my own mistakes first."
Avoid that by modeling the behavior you want to see.
- Admit when you got something wrong and say what you learned from it
- Ask genuine questions before jumping to solutions
- Thank people when they flag a problem, then actually put resources behind fixing it
- Explain the reasoning behind hard calls instead of just announcing them
You can also close out meetings by asking, "What did we miss?" and giving people enough silence to actually answer.
6. Bake it into your processes.
Good intentions fall apart under deadline pressure, but processes won't, as long as you've actually built them into how your team functions.
Add psychological safety checks to your regular team health reviews, right alongside budget and timeline tracking. Take a retrospective look at how each meeting went, how members’ objections or complaints were handled, how each person engaged, productivity results, and measure other pointers of a healthy team culture.
Another way to encourage open communication is through incentives. Create a rewards system for people who speak up, share useful feedback, or help the team collaborate more. Rewards could be as simple as a branded or custom T-shirt from an e-commerce supplier for employees who consistently contribute to team discussions.
Wrapping Up
To build psychological safety into your team culture, first make open communication the default. Then treat every mistake as information for improvement, build empathy into every team process, and keep team goals clear to minimize errors.
Most importantly, you must model the culture you’re trying to build. Show your employees exactly how you want them to handle failures by doing it right in front of them. Lastly, bake each of the steps above into your daily processes and documents.
.svg){kind=small}
.svg)
